NPFL: Referee Committee expels underperforming referees

By Olusola Adebayo 

The Referee Committee has expelled match officials that have been found to have underperformed in the ongoing 2023 NPFL and 2022/2023 NWFL premiership season www.234sportsng.com reports.

The committee headed by Mrs. Faith Irabor came up with outright expulsion of officials who abandons the laws of the game in the discharge of their duties and issued warnings to others who failed to make correct interpretations of the rules after the conclusion of the first evaluation report, which was submitted and endorsed by the Nigeria Football Federation board. 

After a review of the referee's performance in the country's elite league for both male and female teams in the country by the referee committee, the committee established that a few officials had failed to abide by the rules and regulations, failed the diligence test, and have accordingly stepped down from officiating in the league any longer.

Here are the full evaluation report, and sanctions by the Referee Committee as approved by the NFF.

a.           NPFL Matches:

1. Wikki Tourists FC vs Niger Tornadoes FC:
Madu Patience Ndidi (FIFA), Enugu; Referee.

It was identified that an incident occurred in the penalty area, where she whistled and signaled for a penalty kick and instantly changed her decision for a goal as the ball eventually proceeded and resulted in a goal.

After thorough analysis, it was concluded that:

i.  A Foul was committed and the Referee signaled for a Penalty Kick;

ii.  That the goal resulted from a dead ball, and therefore, the advantage clause is not applicable in this instant situation;

iii.  That the Referee should have maintained her decision of penalty kick;

iv.          That she committed an error of judgment in allowing the goal.

Decision:     She is warned and advised to always consider the larger picture by appropriate scanning and delay decisions until there is a clear certainty to justify a decision.

2.   Shooting Stars Sports Club vs Kwara United FC:
Ukah Ndubuisi (FIFA), Imo, Referee Otuwho Morrison, Delta, Assistant Referee 2

It was observed that during a build-up, which resulted in a goal, the AR 2, Otuwho Morrison signaled to the scorer for an offside offense. The Referee complied with his AR to disallow the goal.

After a proper examination of the clip, it was inferred that:

i.  As at the time the ball leaves the leg of the kicker (teammate of the scorer), the scorer was not in an offside position;

ii.   The AR2 was not properly positioned to justify the decision to penalize the scorer for the offside offense.

Decision: The Referee is warned and advised to improve on his  as the duty to identify/establish an offside position is purely that of the AR;

The AR2, Otuwho Morrison is to be stood down from the league

3.  Rivers United vs Niger Tornadoes
Faro Abdulrahman, Lagos, Referee

The committee noted that after a corner kick was taken, the ball traveled into the penalty area with the defending goalkeeper coming out and attempting to parry the ball away, which he missed and an attacking player kicked the ball and scored. The Referee signaled for an infringement to disallow the goal.

The committee explored the video clip thoroughly to  that:

i.  There was no illegal contact that could translate into a foul by the attacking team;

ii.   The decision of the Referee to disallow the goal is not within the provisions of the Laws of the game, and therefore, unjustified.

Decision: The Referee, Faro Abdulrahman is to be stand-down from the league

b.  NWFL Matches 

Though Match Officials’ decisions in one of the NWFL matches (Rivers Angels vs Delta Queens) were characterized by controversial/questionable decisions that had adverse effects on the outcome of the match, the committee however considered the that the impact of the decisions of Match Officials in the other reviewed matches was not serious enough to warrant punitive measures.

1.   Rivers Angels vs Delta Queens
Adesola Olufunke, Oyo, Referee Abdulrasheed Rofiat, Oyo, Assistant Referee 1 Aladenika Adetutu Assistant Referee 2

The committee observed that two goals of Delta Queens were disallowed by the Referee, Adesola Olufunke, and her active Assistant Referee 1, Abdulrasheed Rofiat.

The committee noted that:

i.  In an attack towards the penalty area of Rivers Angels, the defending player attempted a scissors kick and missed the ball;

ii.   None of the two attacking players near the defending player committed no offense;

iii. The claim of the Referee that there was a foul/pushing is unfounded and therefore, her decision to disallow the goal unjustified with the Laws of the Game.

Decision: Referee Adesola Olufunke is to be stand-down from the league

The second goal disallowed by the Assistant Referee’s signal for offside is considered as justified as the committee observed a possible offside situation in the run of the goal by the attacking players. The Assistant Referees are, however, warned and advised to improve in their performances

2.   Osun Babes vs Delta Queens
Ogunboye Joy, Ondo, Referee

Olusi Kikelomo, Ondo, Assistant Referee 1 Ajirotutu Esther, Ondo, Assistant Referee 2
The committee noted that the incidences and errors of judgment of the Match Officials were not serious enough to warrant punitive measures.

Decision: The three (3) Match Officials are warned and advised to improve in their performances.

 

3.   Adamawa Queens vs Nasarawa Amazons
Paul Beatrice, Taraba, Referee

Elizabeth Yunusa, Gombe, Assistant Referee 1 Wuriba Biwuli Ruth, Plateau, Assistant Referee 2

The committee observed that the incidences and errors of judgment of the Match Officials were not serious enough to warrant punitive measures.

Decision: The three (3) Match Officials are warned and advised to improve their performances.

Other cases came up from week 5 of the NPFL, which include the following matches and officials:

1.        Rivers United vs Wikki Tourists
Taiwo David, Oyo, Referee

Charles Isua, Adamawa, Assistant Referee 1 Akinsanya Segun, Oyo, Assistant Referee 2

Decision: The three (3) Match Officials are to be stand-down from the league.

2. Lobi Stars Vs Sunshine Stars
Promise Amadi, Rivers, Referee

Lewis Gwatana, Rivers, Assistant Referee 2
Decision: The Referee and the Assistant Referee 2 are to be stand-down from the league.